A couple random notes for now: (01)
* an interesting piece I read recently about scientific vs humanities
cultures: http://webseitz.fluxent.com/wiki/z2003-07-01-ScientificCulture (02)
* looking at Advogato's network-flow model might be interesting. There
are definitely some big definition problems there, which have never been
corrected - http://webseitz.fluxent.com/wiki/AdvoGato (03)
* DavidBrin's DisputationArena idea smells related -
http://webseitz.fluxent.com/wiki/DisputationArena (04)
The big question which drives the experiment: what's the point? (05)
GoalA, draft0: given the explosion in the quantity of online content
(AOL blogs), how find ideas worth your time, outside your existing
CreativeNetwork and SocialNetwork? (06)
GoalB, draft0: how do we improve the definition of goals/desires, to
improve the likelihood of them being achieved (meta-question - /do/
definition improvements increase likelihood?) (07)
GoalC, draft0: given an agreed-to well-defined goal, evaluate a given
design for achieving the goal, so that (subgoala) better designs can get
more attention than crummy ones, and (subgoalb) all designs can be
improved through feedback. (08)
Peter P. Jones wrote:
> On 24 Jul 2003 at 23:16, Eugene Eric Kim wrote:
>
>
>>As I reported on the yak@collab list, we had an informal gathering of
>>folks in the Bay Area, and one of the topics of discussion was Brian
>>Lincoln's idea for grass roots peer review.
>>
>> http://collab.blueoxen.net/forums/yak/2003-07/msg00159.html#nid06
>>
>
> Looking at the pattern for GrassRootsPeerReview I'm struck by the
> notion that TellAFriend is not the same as FOAF. In my view, in this
> respect FOAF is back-to-front in that I'm the one who declares who my
> friends are (unless I've totally misunderstood how FOAF works in that
> respect). I think that direction is incorrect for TellAFriend
> reviewing.
>
> Perhaps what's needed is a way for folks to register themselves as a
> friend with my friends-node if they wish, anonymously if I allow that
> option, and then every time I stick ratings on something and post it
> into the network they get an indication that I've done that, and it
> stacks up in their personal view of matters.
>
> ?
> (09)
--
This message is archived at: (010)
http://collab.blueoxen.net/forums/cgi-bin/mesg.cgi?a=tools-yak&i=3F2173E8.4030808@fluxent.com (011)
|